Research

The scorelines football fans over- and under-predict

By (@Denveloper), founder of CalledItMate · Published October 2026

We compared 22,221 score predictions made by 971 players on CalledItMate, a free football prediction game, with the final scores of the 5,617 completed matches they were made on, all kicking off between 22 March and 30 September 2026.

0-0 ended 6.1% of matches but got 1.2% of predictions, about a fifth of its share. 2-1 got 17.3% of predictions, more than any other score, and ended 8.5% of matches.

Chart of the five most over-predicted and five most under-predicted final scores. 2-1 was predicted 17.3% of the time and happened 8.5%; 0-0 was predicted 1.2% and happened 6.1%.

Aggregate data: download the CSV. The chart and data are free to use with attribution to CalledItMate. Cite the dataset as doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23154456.

Fans back decisive scores and skip the tight ones

2-1, 1-2, 3-1 took 39.7% of all predictions between them, but ended only 19.3% of matches. The three tightest results went the other way: 1-0, 0-1, 0-0 ended 21.8% of matches between them and got 7.3% of predictions.

1-1 was the most common final score of all (542 matches, 9.6%), and got 5.8% of predictions. The pattern describes what fans predict, not why: the data cannot say whether it is optimism, habit or something else. For draws in detail, see Football fans predict draws half as often as they happen; for goalscorers, see The goalscorers football fans back.

Every common scoreline

Sorted from most over-predicted to most under-predicted. The gap is the share of predictions minus the share of matches, in percentage points. Scorelines are home-away, so 1-2 is an away win by one goal.

ScorePredictionsMatchesGap
2-13,847 (17.3%)478 (8.5%)+8.8
1-22,715 (12.2%)360 (6.4%)+5.8
3-12,251 (10.1%)245 (4.4%)+5.8
2-02,510 (11.3%)387 (6.9%)+4.4
1-31,566 (7.0%)167 (3.0%)+4.1
3-01,517 (6.8%)272 (4.8%)+2.0
0-21,317 (5.9%)244 (4.3%)+1.6
0-3700 (3.2%)139 (2.5%)+0.7
0-4201 (0.9%)54 (1.0%)-0.1
6-019 (0.1%)23 (0.4%)-0.3
0-563 (0.3%)37 (0.7%)-0.4
1-522 (0.1%)27 (0.5%)-0.4
3-44 (0.0%)23 (0.4%)-0.4
4-32 (0.0%)26 (0.5%)-0.5
1-4203 (0.9%)78 (1.4%)-0.5
5-29 (0.0%)31 (0.6%)-0.5
5-077 (0.3%)51 (0.9%)-0.6
4-0405 (1.8%)135 (2.4%)-0.6
2-446 (0.2%)47 (0.8%)-0.6
4-271 (0.3%)56 (1.0%)-0.7
4-1284 (1.3%)110 (2.0%)-0.7
5-134 (0.2%)53 (0.9%)-0.8
3-315 (0.1%)55 (1.0%)-0.9
2-2824 (3.7%)260 (4.6%)-0.9
2-3247 (1.1%)119 (2.1%)-1.0
3-2324 (1.5%)141 (2.5%)-1.1
1-11,283 (5.8%)542 (9.6%)-3.9
0-1516 (2.3%)376 (6.7%)-4.4
0-0266 (1.2%)341 (6.1%)-4.9
1-0831 (3.7%)506 (9.0%)-5.3

Scorelines with fewer than 20 matches and fewer than 100 predictions are left out of the table and the CSV.

Methodology

  • Window: matches that kicked off from 22 March 2026 to 30 September 2026 inclusive (UTC), finished, and have a recorded final score. Data read on 1 October 2026 and frozen.
  • Score prediction: a player's predicted final score for a match, at most one per player per match, as held at kick-off.
  • Shares: a scoreline's share of predictions counts each prediction once; its share of matches counts each match once, among matches that received at least one prediction.
  • Excluded: house accounts run by CalledItMate, internal test matches, and duplicate accounts merged into another account.
  • Same window as the draws study, read later the same day: a few more results had settled and accounts had been merged, so totals here (22,221 predictions, 5,617 matches) are slightly higher than that study's. Quote each study with its own totals.
  • Limitations: CalledItMate players are a self-selected group of football fans, not a random sample of the public, and the competition mix follows what they chose to predict.

Questions, league or club breakdowns, or the chart in another format: email hello@calleditmate.com.

Play CalledItMate free →